The Comic
Spirit
Project I: Peer Assessment
Results
Critically rate each of the scenes that you did not participate in for the categories listed below, using a scale of (-) 1 to 5 (+). Try not to be influenced by the performance.
|
CATEGORY |
Scene 1 |
Scene 2 |
Scene 3 |
Scene 4 |
|
CHARACTERS |
4.4 | 4.3 | 4.4 | 4.4 |
|
PLOT |
4.1 | 4.3 | 4.4 | 4.3 |
|
DIALOGUE |
4.5 | 4.3 | 4.1 | 4.4 |
Comment below on the Strengths and Weakness of each scene:
|
Scene 1: The Consul of Golf Strengths: Dialogue, characters, plot funny; well researched; modernized plot; well prepared; group worked well together; good farce Weaknesses: talked too fast and low; plot confusing and without point; needed length and substance; acting |
|
Scene 2: The Sun of Deceit Strengths: acting; creative; funny; good dialogue; clear plot and organized; variety; use of disguise Weaknesses: confusing dialogue (especially with characters switched); hard to understand; jumpy; length; confused plot; too long; characters needed to be more stereotyped |
|
Scene 3: The Best Kept Secret Strengths: characters well presented; use of surprise; funny plot and dialogue Weaknesses: too short; couldn't recognize stock characters; choppy and struggling performance |
|
Scene 4: Lover's Groove Strengths: dialogue; chorus; use of farce; clever modernization; well-researched; funny; organized Weaknesses: acting; confusing plot and characters; why chorus?; not ancient; weird; too long |
Name the Winner and explain why you chose that scene: Scene
4
The reasons listed for all the votes: play didn't drag; performance;
good plot with clever twist; laughed; interesting; group worked well as a
team
Name your Runner-up and explain why you chose that scene: Tie
between Scenes 1 and 2
The reasons listed for all the votes: Plot: funny
and clear, interesting, modernization, original; play on words; humorous
characters; well-researched, chorus unusual.